Search This Blog

Saturday, January 15, 2011

Help Ban the Pesticide That's Wiping Out Honey Bees

A Slow Moving Crisis for Honey Bees has been wiping out hives for the last several years. 
Colony Collapse Disorder is the term used for the devastation afflicting the honey bee populations. 

CREDO is championing the cause by calling for the Ban of clothianidin, is produced by the German corporation Bayer Crop Science.  Their petition site is an effective way to take action on this issue.

And it's about more than just the honey that we love. Honey Bees are an essential element of agriculture and our food production in this country and worldwide. The USDA has a site to answer questions on the subject.
"Bee pollination is responsible for $15 billion in added crop value, particularly for specialty crops such as almonds and other nuts, berries, fruits, and vegetables. About one mouthful in three in the diet directly or indirectly benefits from honey bee pollination."
If you want to attract bees to your yard for pollination
check out WDFW's site and Russell Link's books
Since 2006, U.S. honey bee populations have been in precipitous decline, with some estimates suggesting losses as high as 30% per year.1 While that's terrible, the problem is far greater than just the destruction of a species. Without bees, a big piece of our food supply is in serious danger. Pollination by honey bees is key in cultivating the crops that produce a full one-third of our food.
Scientists have been scrambling to understand the crisis -- termed Colony Collapse Disorder -- but have yet to find a single, definitive cause. There are likely multiple interacting causes, and mounting evidence suggests that one widely used class of pesticides may be a critical factor.
One such chemical, called clothianidin, is produced by the German corporation Bayer CropScience. It is used as a treatment on crop seeds, including corn and canola, and works by expressing itself in the plants' pollen and nectar. Not coincidentally, these are honey bees' favorite sources of food.
Shockingly, no major independent study has verified the safety of this pesticide. While clothianidin has been used on corn -- the largest crop in the U.S. -- since 2003, it was officially approved by the Environmental Protection Agency last year on the basis of a single study, conducted by Bayer. However, recently leaked documents show that the study was actually debunked by the agency's own scientists, so the pesticide was effectively approved with no scientific backing.2
It is outrageous that the E.P.A. is putting a vital species, the livelihoods of farmers and beekeepers, and our very food supply at risk just so Bayer can peddle its pesticide.
When clothianidin first came to market, there was little or no scientific review of its effect on the environment. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency allowed "conditional registration" in 2003 but requested additional study to establish the safety of the chemical. Bayer, the producer of the chemical, conducted one such study, and without public notice, the E.P.A. granted unconditional use in early 2010.
But E.P.A. documents3 leaked at the end of last year expose a more sordid story. Agency scientists who reviewed Bayer's study determined that the evidence was by no means sound, and even downgraded the study to a level at which it should not have been allowed as the basis for an unconditional approval of the pesticide.
Additional independent studies have shown that neonicotinoid pesticides like clothianidin are highly toxic to honey bees, providing compelling evidence that they should be immediately taken off the market until the E.P.A. can conduct a full and valid scientific review.
This appears to be a case of the E.P.A. catering to the needs of a large chemical corporation at the expense of a lynchpin species in our ecosystem. France, Italy, Slovenia, and Germany -- the home of Bayer -- have already banned clothianidin.
The stakes are simply too high to continue the use of this chemical in the absence of any scientifically verified evidence that it is safe to use. Tell the E.P.A. to immediately prohibit the use of clothianidin and conduct a full scientific review to determine its impact on honey bee populations.


  1. Scientists at the EPA apparently understand the necessity of following "the precautionary principle", but not so the EPA administration under Bush to start with and continuing under Obama.

    This principle can be thought of as the scientist's equivalent of the MD's Hippocratic Oath to do no harm. The principle requires one to err on the side of caution when contemplating an action that could entail negative or unforeseen consequences. Only after affirmative studies show that the action is safe does one proceed.

    The EPA administration apparently prefers an "incautious principle", namely, go ahead until harm is done, and only then consider backing off, but only after you have absolute proof of cause and effect.

    This philosophy is bad for people and the entire planet. It's way past time for it to be confronted and ended.

  2. I appreciate having real news sources (as compared to Major Corporate owned and Faux News sources) like WikiLeaks to report such news worthy news. Thank you, courageous WikiLeaks for this leak.